Next Contract: Tee Higgins

Michael Ginnitti
Michael Ginnitti, Managing Editor & NFL/MLB ExpertFebruary 05, 2025
Share
#tee higgins #next contract series #nfl #nfl free agency
© USA TODAY Sports

Tee Higgins, a 2nd round draft pick out of Clemson back in 2020 could finally find himself on the open market this March. The barely 26-year-old was franchise tagged by the Bengals in 2024, earning $21,816,000 in his 5th NFL season. Spotrac dives into the future contract status for Higgins as the 2025 league year approaches.

The Second Franchise Tag

While the Bengals have big fish to fry this offseason (a record-setting Ja’Marr Chase extension, keeping Trey Hendrickson happy, completely rebuilding the defense, etc…) tagging Higgins for the second straight season isn’t THAT financially crazy.

Franchise tagging a player for the second time comes at a 120% increase of their first tag, or in Higgins’ case, $26,179,200.

The Bengals enter 2025 with $234M of cap allocated for 55/90 contracts, giving them around $49M of Top 51 cap space. A base salary conversion on QB Joe Burrow’s contract can free up another $19.2M, while an extension for WR Ja'Marr Chase will almost certainly lower his current $21.8M cap figure as well. Those two moves alone should be enough to account for a second Higgins tag to begin the league year.

With this said, Higgins and his camp won’t be pleased with the restrictive move, and it’s highly unlikely that the tag is signed at any point in time. The Bengals could look to shop Higgins, seeking a deal that would bring back a bigger return than the single compensatory draft pick that would come from simply letting him walk in free agency this March. This route can be risky, as Higgins will need to sign the franchise tag in order to process the trade, meaning he’ll get to pick/choose his next destination. It also requires teams to have ample cap space to be able to take on the $26.2M tag number.

Still, with a weak free agent market for WRs, and a potentially underwhelming draft class for the position as well, the tag & trade scenario could prove fruitful for the Bengals, and a “best of both worlds” endgame for both sides. The last WR to be tag/traded was Davante Adams from Green Bay to Las Vegas back in 2022. The Packers received a 1st & 2nd round pick in the 2022 draft per the move, and 30-year-old Adams secured a 5 year, $140 million contract extension.

If Higgins is tagged, he would have until July 15, 2025 to come to terms on a multi-year extension (with whatever team he happens to be on).

Calculated Market Value

The math hasn’t been kind to Higgins as he approaches his first monster payday. A combination of time missed, drops, and a 4 catch, 65 yards per game average over the past 2 seasons keeps the overall price point somewhat tempered.

At the time of this piece, the calculated value of a Tee Higgins contract according to our system clocks in at 4 years, $102M. Fortunately for Higgins, there are plenty of other factors in play that will certainly amplify these figures.

An Extension to Stay

It’s not inconceivable that the Bengals simply agree to pay both Ja’Marr Chase & Tee Higgins this Spring, however this scenario should be considered highly unlikely for now. Chase has the resume to completely reset this position’s financial market, currently set at $35M per year, $110M guaranteed thanks to Justin Jefferson. So where would Higgins fit in under this?

Two teams have recently locked in their top two wide receivers to big-time contracts: Tyreek Hill & Jaylen Waddle in Miami, A.J. Brown & DeVonta Smith in Philadelphia.

While Brown maxed out, Smith secured 9.8% of the cap last year on his $25M per year extension. If we adjust that to a projected $275M league salary cap in 2025, that would mean a deal right around $27M per year for Higgins, or a 4 year, $108M extension. 

Smith also secured 68% of his new money as guaranteed. For Higgins, this would mean $74M, a big number for a “number 2”, but the precedent that one of the best teams in football has now set. Waddle, by the way, secured $76M practically guaranteed on his 3 year, $85M extension in Miami. In other words, a figure around $75M isn’t out of bounds for Tee Higgins going forward.

Is $108M over the next 4 years, $75M practically guaranteed enough to keep Higgins from hitting the open market this March?

A Free Agent Contract

If Higgins is allowed to hit the open market untethered, the sky is seemingly the limit. However: the largest free agent wide receiver contract ever handed out came last year, Calvin Ridley’s 4 year, $92M contract that included $50M guaranteed. Yes, times have changed, the cap has changed, and players of Higgins’ age and ability rarely get to free agency, but there isn’t a precedent for players to “max-out” on the open market like we see in other sports.

With that said, things are lining up nicely for multiple teams (many with quarterbacks on rookie contracts) to step in and generate a bidding war for Higgins’ services. We’ll factor this momentum into our bottom line.

The most likely foundation point for Higgins in a free market is Brandon Aiyuk’s 4 year, $120 million extension with the 49ers. The deal includes $76M guaranteed for practical purposes, $45M fully guaranteed at signing. In direct comparison over the past two seasons (2023-24 for Higgins, 2022-23 for Aiyuk), the numbers are fairly close, with Aiyuk slightly ahead in almost all of these standard receiving categories, holding a sizable lead over him in touchdowns.
At $30M per year, Aiyuk secured 11.7% of the 2024 salary cap on an average basis. If we assume a $275M salary cap in 2025, this represents a $32.1M APY for a WR with similar comparables.

So here’s the million-dollar question: Does the combination of Tee Higgins’ resume PLUS the idea of a free agent bidding war, warrant a cap-adjusted increase of the Brandon Aiyuk contract? Yes. If teams such as New England, Washington, Denver, Atlanta, etc…will all collectively be making offers, it stands to reason that (at least) one will go above and beyond mathematical logic to get their guy.

Using Spotrac’s Free Agent Contract Builder tool, here’s our latest full breakdown projection for Tee Higgins this coming March:


It’s a 4 year, $124 million contract that includes $59.25M fully guaranteed at signing (3rd among WRs). The $31M per year APY would rank him 4th, while a $74.25M practical guarantee over the next 3 seasons would be 9th most.

The deal has a whopping $91M cash built into the first three seasons, 4th most among WRs and WELL ahead of Brandon Aiyuk ($76M). A double-bonus structure ($28.8M signing bonus, $28M 2026 option bonus) plus the use of void years keep the cap hits at bay early on, with conversion possibilities built into 2027 as needed.

It’s a 3 year, $91M contract for practical purposes, a huge upgrade for a player that has never mathematically approached a $30M valuation in our system. But supply, demand, and rookie QB contracts are real, and in cases like this, they can be spectacular too.


#tee higgins #next contract series #nfl #nfl free agency
Top