Restricted Free Agency is the last bastion of old-school “teams hold all the power” contract status in the NBA. In a league that has become increasingly player-friendly in terms of players getting paid, teams can still wield the restricted hammer over players. Sure, some restricted free agents get paid, but other times players languish on the market until they have no choice but to re-sign with their teams.
We’re going to look at what some former first-round picks might be looking at in restricted free agency this summer. To better understand that, we’re going to look back at the recent history of restricted free agency.
Over the last five offseasons from 2020 through 2024, a total of 26 former first-round picks have reached restricted free agency. That’s an average of just over five players per offseason.
This offseason, we have a whopping 10 former first-round picks who are pending restricted free agents.
Below are the former first-round picks who reached restricted free agency over the last five years and what ultimately happened with those players and their next contract.
- 2020: Malik Beasley – Minnesota Timberwolves – re-signed for four years, $60 million
- 2020: Juancho Hernangomez – Minnesota Timberwolves – re-signed for three years, $21 million
- 2020: Brandon Ingram – New Orleans Pelicans – re-signed for five years, $158 million
- 2020: Jako Poeltl – San Antonio Spurs – re-signed for three years, $27 million
- 2020: Dario Saric – Phoenix Suns – re-signed for three years, $27 million
- 2020: Denzel Valentine – Chicago Bulls – re-signed for one year, $4.6 million (signed Qualifying Offer)
- 2021: Lonzo Ball – Chicago Bulls – signed-and-traded for four years, $85 million
- 2021: John Collins – Atlanta Hawks – re-signed for five years, $125 million
- 2021: Josh Hart – New Orleans Pelicans – re-signed for three years, $38 million
- 2021: Lauri Markkanen – Cleveland Cavaliers – signed-and-traded for four years, $67 million
- 2022: Deandre Ayton – Phoenix Suns – matched offer sheet for four years, $133 million
- 2022: Marvin Bagley III – Detroit Pistons – re-signed for three years, $37 million
- 2022: Miles Bridges – Charlotte Hornets – Unsigned (suspended for season)
- 2022: Collin Sexton – Utah Jazz – signed-and-traded for four years, $72 million
- 2022: Anfernee Simons – Portland Trail Blazers – re-signed for four years, $100 million
- 2023: Rui Hachimura – Los Angeles Lakers – re-signed for three years, $51 million
- 2023: Cameron Johnson – Brooklyn Nets – re-signed for four years, $108 million
- 2023: Matisse Thybulle – Portland Trail Blazers – matched offer sheet for three years, $33 million
- 2023: P.J. Washington – Charlotte Hornets – re-signed for three years, $48 million
- 2023: Coby White – Chicago Bulls – re-signed for three years, $40 million
- 2023: Grant Williams – Dallas Mavericks – signed-and-traded for 4 years, $54 million
- 2024 Tyrese Maxey – Philadelphia 76ers – re-signed for five years, $204 million
- 2024: Isaac Okoro – Cleveland Cavaliers – re-signed for three years, $38 million
- 2024: Immanuel Quickley – Toronto Raptors – re-signed for five years, $175 million
- 2024: Obi Toppin – Indiana Pacers – re-signed for four years, $60 million
- 2024: Patrick Williams – Chicago Bulls – re-signed for five years, $90 million
Here’s the breakdown:
- Re-signed on a max deal: Three players (one matched offer sheet)
- Re-signed for less than max: 17 players (one matched offer sheet)
- Re-signed on qualifying offer: One player
- Changed teams via sign-and-trade: Four players
- Unsigned: One player
Out of 26 former first-round picks to reach restricted free agency, all but five returned to their incumbent team the next season. Only three got max contracts. And only two total players garnered offer sheets.
Within that breakdown, there’s a little context needed.
Brandon Ingram was coming off a serious, career-threatening blood clot condition before re-signing with the Pelicans. Tyrese Maxey and the Sixers agreed to delay his re-signing to allow Philadelphia to create the most cap space possible.
Of the players to change teams, all four did so via sign-and-trade. Within that group of four, both Lauri Markkanen and Collin Sexton had to wait until deep into free agency to get their new deals via sign-and-trade situations.
And, just in case you think the “just sign the qualifying offer and hit unrestricted free agency in the next summer” is a viable path, we’ve seen one player go that route. And, sadly, Denzel Valentine was out of the league after only one more season. Teams have increasingly declined to tender a qualifying offer as opposed to allowing a player to sign and become an unrestricted free agent a year later.
To recap: A grand total of three players got max contracts, and one was coming off injury concerns, one was pre-arranged and one took an offer sheet to get his max deal.
Now, to be fair, several other players got really nice contracts. John Collins, Immanuel Quickley, Cameron Johnson and Anfernee Simons all reached the $100 million marker, while Patrick Williams came up just short of that amount.
Of that group, the jury is still somewhat out on Quickley’s deal (Reminder: Quickley ranks 20th in terms of AAV among NBA point guards for the 2024-25 season. Meaning: It’s a better deal than you think it is.), but the rest are all largely fine. Collins has proven to be a bit overpaid, but Johnson and Simons have delivered solid value on their deals.
Several other players got a contract in range of the Non-Taxpayer MLE or less. To be fair again, only a couple of players got truly got squeezed and outplayed their deals. Jakob Poeltl and Josh Hart both garnered significantly bigger deals on their third contracts. That’s where Coby White seems headed too.
For everyone else, they got paid somewhere between fair and a slight overpay. And a handful of others (Juancho Hernangomez, Dario Saric, Marvin Bagley III) all got bigger deals than they should have.
One other interesting note: Of the 26 former first-round picks to hit restricted free agency since 2020, 12 of them were traded while on the deal they were re-signed to (excluding sign-and-traded players, since the trade was part of the original transaction). Can we all that “re-signers remorse”?
While restricted free agency has been tough on players, it’s largely worked out ok for them. Only three players seem to have gotten truly squeezed as restricted free agents. Sure, only a few got max deals, but the vast majority of restricted free agents still came out with a pretty nice payday.
But…where players are truly impacted is with their ability to change teams. Only four total players changed teams (Again: all via sign-and-trade, in which the incumbent team has some measure of control), and only two others even signed offer sheets. That’s roughly a 15% change rate.
The ability to change teams has been extremely limited. And that’s some history we can expect to repeat itself this offseason.
There are 10 former first-round picks who are pending restricted free agents for the 2025 offseason. By original draft slot, these are the 10 pending RFAs and their qualifying offers:
- Josh Giddey: Chicago Bulls – $11.1 million qualifying offer
- Jonthan Kuminga: Golden State Warriors – $10.2 million qualifying offer
- Davion Mitchell: Miami Heat – $7.9 million qualifying offer*
- Ziaire Williams: Brooklyn Nets – $7.9 million qualifying offer
- Tre Mann: Charlotte Hornets – $6.9 million qualifying offer
- Isaiah Jackson: Indiana Pacers – $6.4 million qualifying offer
- Quentin Grimes: Philadelphia 76ers – $6.3 million qualifying offer*
- Cam Thomas: Brooklyn Nets – $5.9 million qualifying offer
- Day’Ron Sharpe: Brooklyn Nets – $5.9 million qualifying offer
- Santi Aldama: Memphis Grizzlies – $5.9 million qualifying offer
*Both Davion Mitchell and Quentin Grimes could still reach Starter Criteria. If so, that would see Mitchell’s and Grimes’ qualifying offers come in at $8.7 million.
Looking at this group, we can pretty confidently take Ziaire Williams, Tre Mann and Isaiah Jackson out of the mix. If any of those three players receive their qualifying offer, they’d do well to simply sign it. Mann and Jackson are coming off season-ending injuries, while Williams simply hasn’t produced at a level worth $7.9 million.
That leaves seven players in the balance. Of the remaining seven players, Cam Thomas and Day’Ron Sharpe are in a somewhat weird spot. They both play for the Brooklyn Nets, who happen to be the only team that is projected to have cap space this summer. So, their situation won’t likely be driven by offer sheets, since the most a team could offer them would be the Non-Taxpayer MLE.
Now we’re down to five players. And those five all have pretty interesting situations.
Josh Giddey and Jonathan Kuminga both have enough prospect shine left on them to make them “future investment” candidates. Quentin Grimes has certainly shown enough with Philadelphia that we’ll put him in the same category.
Davion Mitchell and Santi Aldama are both high-end rotation players, but haven’t established themselves as starters yet.
Now, as we referenced above, market factors heavily influence restricted free agency. In this case, only one team having cap space is going to make it really tough on the 2025 RFA group.
Could the Nets throw a big offer sheet at Giddey, Kuminga or Grimes? Sure. All of them are young enough and talented enough to go that route.
It's worth pausing here to note that Sean Marks has played in restricted free agency when he’s had cap space before. The Nets gave offer sheets to Allen Crabbe, Tyler Johnson and Otto Porter Jr. several years ago. All three offer sheets were matched, but Marks isn’t afraid to force a rival team to pay up to keep their players.
In the case of Kuminga and Grimes, both of their incumbent teams (Warriors and 76ers, respectively) are facing luxury tax and apron issues. If Brooklyn gave either Kuminga or Grimes anything approaching a max offer sheet (projected starting salary of $38.7 million in 2025-26), their current teams might blink at matching.
Giddey is in a bit of a different spot. He’s kind of, sort of as close to the centerpiece of the Bulls young core as they have. Giddey has been solid all season, but since the calendar flipped to 2025, he’s gone to a different level. In 32 games since January 1, Giddey has averaged 15.4 points on 48/44/82 shooing splits, 8.4 rebounds, 6.8 assists and 1.4 steals per game. If you believe in that shooting, combined with the other production, that’s approaching max contract territory.
Here’s the challenge though: Giddey, Kuminga and Grimes will be 23, 23 and 25 at the start of the 2025-26 season. That’s hardly ancient, but given that the Nets are in the early stages of their rebuild, that would be a major commitment for any of these three players.
And therein lies the issue for the 2025 RFA group: The Nets are the only team that can realistically sign any of the RFAs to an offer sheet that would cause their teams to have to swallow hard while making a decision to match.
That means, as per usual, most of the 2025 RFA group is likely to re-sign with their own team. A couple could change teams via sign-and-trade, but that’s really hard to project.
As we project the next contract for each of the pending RFAs, we’re going to assume they’ll be re-signing with their current teams. We’re using a combination of history combined with updated market factors, as well as future improvement forecasts to drive these projections.
Josh Giddey
Projected Next Contract: four years, $108 million
Analysis: Considering the Bulls gave Patrick Williams $18 million a year over five years, and he’s never shown as much as Giddey has, we’re bumping Giddey’s number up. We’re also knocking a year off, as Giddey isn’t going to fetch a player option on his final season, so he’ll likely only want to lock in for four years.
Jonathan Kuminga
Projected Next Contract: four years, $100 million
Analysis: Kuminga has been less reliable than Giddey, but he’s got higher upside. Kuminga still has “primary scorer on a good team” potential. He’s also the best, and last, of the Warriors “two timelines” prospects left. This is a pretty heavy investment, but Kuminga is worth nearly as much as the more-proven Giddey, simply given the untapped upside he still has.
Davion Mitchell
Projected Next Contract: four years, $40 million
Analysis: Mitchell has been solid enough as a backup point guard. When you adjust for his ability to also start, Mitchell’s value bumps just shy of the Non-Taxpayer MLE amount. The Heat don’t have a lot of point guard depth and Miami values locking players up on long-term team-friendly deals when they can.
Ziaire Williams
Projected Next Contract: Veteran Minimum
Analysis: Williams has played better with Nets, but he’s unlikely to get tendered a qualifying offer. That will make him an unrestricted free agent. From there, Williams will probably have to take a minimum deal to continue finding his way in the NBA.
Tre Mann
Projected Next Contract: two years, $11 million
Analysis: Mann has shown he can score and can be an NBA rotation player. Getting hurt this year really killed his chances at getting a bigger deal. Had he stayed healthy, he might have been looking at something in the range of $10-15 million AAV. As it stands, he’s likely to be more in the range of the Taxpayer MLE, if even that. Charlotte likely won’t issue the combo guard the qualifying offer. It wouldn’t be a surprise if Mann had to take a minimum deal and work his way back from there.
Isaiah Jackson
Projected Next Contract: Veteran Minimum
Analysis: Jackson will be coming of a torn Achilles. If he had stayed healthy, there was a good chance Jackson would have landed a deal around $8-10 million AAV. Now, he’ll likely have to take a minimum deal to prove he’s healthy. Also, don’t expect Indiana to tender a qualifying offer to Jackson. If they do, he’d be smart to sign it immediately.
Quentin Grimes
Projected Next Contract: four years, $100 million
This one is based on potential, need and fit with the 76ers. Because of their cap/tax/apron situation, it’s going to be hard for Philadelphia to add outside talent for the next few years. That means it’s imperative to keep a guy like Grimes. $25 million AAV might seem like a lot, but Grimes has shown he can do more than just being a 3&D guy. He should also be a really solid fit with Tyrese Maxey and Jared McCain in a three-guard rotation for the Sixers moving forward.
Cam Thomas
Projected Next Contract: three years, $45 million
Analysis: Thomas can score. He’s a better playmaker than most realize. The Nets aren’t in a position to let young talent walk out the door, but Brooklyn can’t start overpaying guys yet either. Unless there’s a team that falls in love and wants to work a sign-and-trade deal for Thomas, expect Brooklyn to get him back on a solid value contract. Think what Coby White signed for, plus a bit to represent the new cap environment. From there, it’s up to Thomas to outplay the deal, much like White has.
Day’Ron Sharpe
Projected Next Contract: three years, $30 million
Analysis: Sharpe is essentially the big man equivalent of teammate Cam Thomas. The Nets can’t just let him walk, but bigs don’t generally get paid as much as scoring wings/guards do. And Brooklyn already has Nic Claxton and Noah Clowney under contract too. That’ll push Sharpe’s deal down a bit, but he should still get a nice payday.
Santi Aldama
Projected Next Contract: four years, $60 million
Analysis: This is essentially the equivalent to the Non-Taxpayer MLE. Aldama has improved every year he’s been in the league, and that’s maintained as his role has grown. The Grizzlies cap situation is getting a bit tight, especially when you factor in Jaren Jackson Jr. is due a new starting in 2026-27. This could be one where another team works a sign-and-trade, that way Memphis can keep their books in order, but doesn’t lose Aldama for nothing. Think the equivalent to Grant Williams leaving the Boston Celtics for the Dallas Mavericks a few years back.